tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post3937870824656508599..comments2024-03-29T12:56:11.987+01:00Comments on MY JANE AUSTEN BOOK CLUB: TALKING JANE AUSTEN AND DICKENS WITH ... BARBARA TILLER COLE + GIVEAWAYMaria Graziahttp://www.blogger.com/profile/08876779286144473782noreply@blogger.comBlogger25125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-58840025972016421112011-12-28T03:16:35.206+01:002011-12-28T03:16:35.206+01:00Oh my! Im so excited to participate in this giveaw...Oh my! Im so excited to participate in this giveaway! I think is amazing to mix two lovely book in one delightful story and with Mr. Darcy as main character, sigh! Please I would like to win! :)<br />I'm so grateful to have the opportunity of enjoying the amazing novels of Jane Austen and i don't know why still are people who don't give classics novels a chance to be enjoyed.<br />- I love how in the interview Barbara described Mr. Darcy: "I think the overall reason that he is a hero beyond time is that he was willing to change. Mr. Darcy was a man that had everything he could ever want, except the love of a woman he wanted to be his wife. Guess what? He changed in order to secure her love." (I LOVE IT, sigh)<br />- And about the least happy couple?<br />I was shock too, but thinking about it, you are right, if you put your mind to it, Jane and Bingley probably were ok or fine with each other but the relationship would never be that strong like Darcy and Elizabeth.<br /><br />Thank you so much for this interview I enjoy it so so much, and i'm crossing fingers here, I would LOVE to read this book!! <br /><br />ilepachequin(at)hotmail(dot)comGigihttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17964875845906599131noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-11246008566816988632011-12-26T00:52:40.978+01:002011-12-26T00:52:40.978+01:00[MonicaP said...
Interesting take on Jane and Char...[MonicaP said...<br />Interesting take on Jane and Charles, I never really thought about it. I do agree that he is too easily lead, and I always hoped that he learned from it and grew a pair. Lol I do think theyd have been happier than Charlotte and Mr Collins (well, maybe just Charlotte. I dont think Collins was smart enough to realize his wife detests him). <br /><br />I dont know how anyone could not love Mr Darcy! He's my #1 for sure. I didnt like the Macfadyen version, either. <br /><br />Cant wait to read FED!]<br /><br />Monica:<br /><br />I am glad you enjoyed my thoughts about Jane and Charles. I know that they might be a bit provocative. But I just see Charles so weak that he was so easily led, and fickle. And Jane in her attempt to see the best in everyone, blind to the true nature of people. Perhaps that is a recipe for happiness? But I suspect that neither of them really knew themselves and would be terrified to truly be honest with each other--especially about their feelings about Carolyn who was most likely living with them. And as said in P&P, there were many who were likely to cheat them. Hopefully they would not be cheated so badly that Bingley completely lost his shirt.<br /><br />I thought of Mr. And Mrs. Collins as well. But Charlotte seemed delighted in P&P to have her own home. And so proud to show it off. She told Elizabeth that she was not romantic. I some how think that she was content to have her own life...and while I am SURE that life with Mr. Collins was a trial, I don't think that they would have been the MOST unhappy couple in Jane Austen literature.<br /><br />Those that married simply for economic and connection reason were probably content. My FIRST thought was Carolyn Bingley and whomever found themselves married to her. But they would have been happy with her money and she would have been happy with their connections...even if they never saw each other.<br /><br />Have a wonderful holiday, Monica!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-20218544766241157132011-12-26T00:45:12.493+01:002011-12-26T00:45:12.493+01:00[Laura Ferrari said...
This sounds delightful!
I w...[Laura Ferrari said...<br />This sounds delightful!<br />I would love to read it, especially now that it's Christmas and I've just finished rereading A Christmas carol.<br />Merry Christmas ladies!]<br /><br />Laura:<br /><br />I hope that you have had a wonderful Christams and enjoyed your re-read of A Christmas Carol! Hope you get a chance to read this somewhere along the line!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-17514021238419444192011-12-26T00:43:51.452+01:002011-12-26T00:43:51.452+01:00[Viola said...
I would love to read the book! Darc...[Viola said...<br />I would love to read the book! Darcy is one of my favourite heroes, although I think that Henry Tilney is less intimidating. I couldn't live up to Mr Darcy.<br /><br />I agree that Elizabeth and Darcy were probably the happiest couple. However, I think that Jane and Bingley aren't shallow. They see the best in everyone, which can be a good thing. Jane is, in fact, more understanding about Darcy in Pride & Prejudice and her advice to Lizzy is that she is too quick to judge. She is right!]<br /><br />Viola:<br /><br />I love your thoughts on these questions. Henry Tilney IS perhaps much less intimidating, but Mr. Darcy--ahhh...he is just Darcy to me.. :D<br /><br />As to Jane and Charles, you ARE correct, that Jane was able to give Mr. Darcy more the benefit of the doubt because he was Mr. Bingley's friend. And even if she thought that because she wanted to think the best about everyone, and she KNEW that her Mr. Bingley couldn't have a friend who would do such a thing. I have always been bothered by the fact that Jane just accepted all the praise from her mother and never seemed to ever defend Elizabeth. I don't KNOW that she was stuck up and thought better of herself because she BELiEVED her self to be the most beautiful or not, but I could see that that could have been the case. It is just a personal prejudice! Honestly. But then again, perhaps I like to express opinions that are not truly my own in an impertinent attempt to be provocative!<br /><br />Have a Very Merry Christmas, Viola! And thanks for commenting!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-45866544658536105072011-12-26T00:38:57.498+01:002011-12-26T00:38:57.498+01:00[cyn209 said...
already added onto my WishList!!!
...[cyn209 said...<br />already added onto my WishList!!!<br /><br />another twist that i cannot wait to read!!<br /><br />thank you for the giveaway!!!]<br /><br />Cyn:<br /><br />I am honored to have my book on your WishList! Hope you had a very happy Christmas! And Good luck!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller Cole!Barbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-55141427059699417182011-12-26T00:37:42.007+01:002011-12-26T00:37:42.007+01:00[Barbara is quite an adventurous, fearless writer ...[Barbara is quite an adventurous, fearless writer to tackle two classics. I bow down and touch your feet, authoress.<br /><br />Btw, great interview. Very provocative, thoughtful questions that made me think. <br /><br />I disagree with my friend Barbara. I think Charles and Jane are very happy because their expectation of marital felicity differs from the grand passion that we sense Darcy & Elizabeth would have. The grand passion isn't for everyone, (and really, who wants to read about Jane and Charles' grand passion!)...and vanilla ice cream goes a long way over rocky roads. ;)]<br /><br />Nina:<br /><br />I thank you for your kind words, but I have always suspected that you like to process opinions that are not your own..LOL. <br /><br />As for Jane and Charles, I do understand your opinion, but I spent a great deal of time contemplating this question. Think about it! Jane and Charles find themselves married, and neither of them wants to think anything except the best about everyone that they know. Jane has learned that Carolyn does not always have the best of intentions, however, now her sister in law is most likely living with them and trying to run HER household. And Jane is too nice to do anything about it, OR to be able to SAY anything to Bingley about it. Bingley does not have the gumption to stand up to his sister (I know--there are many fan fiction versions in which he does, but as to the original novel? I just don't see the Bingley of P&P doing it.) and Jane and Charles are both very unhappy to have her under their feet, but hopeless to do a thing about it, or to even discuss it. They TRY to live naively through their life, but they begin to move further and further away from each other as they DO have feelings but are terrified to express them to anyone--much less each other and slowly become less and less happy. <br /><br />But then again...Maybe I like to express opinions that are not truly my own! :D<br /><br />I would LOVE to hear YOUR answer to this question Nina! <br /><br />Have a wonderful Merry Christmas...<br /><br />BarbaraBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-81047083348785008572011-12-25T14:59:55.315+01:002011-12-25T14:59:55.315+01:00Interesting take on Jane and Charles, I never real...Interesting take on Jane and Charles, I never really thought about it. I do agree that he is too easily lead, and I always hoped that he learned from it and grew a pair. Lol I do think theyd have been happier than Charlotte and Mr Collins (well, maybe just Charlotte. I dont think Collins was smart enough to realize his wife detests him). <br /><br />I dont know how anyone could not love Mr Darcy! He's my #1 for sure. I didnt like the Macfadyen version, either. <br /><br />Cant wait to read FED!MonicaPhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15059381106713282439noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-75349918583078257592011-12-25T08:41:34.184+01:002011-12-25T08:41:34.184+01:00This sounds delightful!
I would love to read it, e...This sounds delightful!<br />I would love to read it, especially now that it's Christmas and I've just finished rereading A Christmas carol.<br />Merry Christmas ladies!<br /><br />lallyjx@libero.itLaura Ferrarihttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05662085376166792954noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-33005636066591282202011-12-24T23:26:35.624+01:002011-12-24T23:26:35.624+01:00I would love to read the book! Darcy is one of my...I would love to read the book! Darcy is one of my favourite heroes, although I think that Henry Tilney is less intimidating. I couldn't live up to Mr Darcy.<br /><br />I agree that Elizabeth and Darcy were probably the happiest couple. However, I think that Jane and Bingley aren't shallow. They see the best in everyone, which can be a good thing. Jane is, in fact, more understanding about Darcy in Pride & Prejudice and her advice to Lizzy is that she is too quick to judge. She is right!Violahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08046603677301666579noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-34735162755335118842011-12-24T04:11:02.784+01:002011-12-24T04:11:02.784+01:00already added onto my WishList!!!
another twist t...already added onto my WishList!!!<br /><br />another twist that i cannot wait to read!!<br /><br />thank you for the giveaway!!!<br /><br />cyn209 at juno dot comcyn209https://www.blogger.com/profile/15389416408969526333noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-42660814596283008132011-12-23T20:59:20.895+01:002011-12-23T20:59:20.895+01:00Barbara is quite an adventurous, fearless writer t...Barbara is quite an adventurous, fearless writer to tackle two classics. I bow down and touch your feet, authoress.<br /><br /> Btw, great interview. Very provocative, thoughtful questions that made me think. <br /><br />I disagree with my friend Barbara. I think Charles and Jane are very happy because their expectation of marital felicity differs from the grand passion that we sense Darcy & Elizabeth would have. The grand passion isn't for everyone, (and really, who wants to read about Jane and Charles' grand passion!)...and vanilla ice cream goes a long way over rocky roads. ;)Nina Bennetonnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-84507586918433144022011-12-23T19:18:53.576+01:002011-12-23T19:18:53.576+01:00[ Anonymous said...
Nice interwiev! Thanks Maria G...[ Anonymous said...<br />Nice interwiev! Thanks Maria Grazia.<br />I agree with the author when she says that Mr. Darcy is a hero because of his being willing to change.<br />I think JA enjoyed herself a lot in creating a proud character just to put him later through the most "embarassing" situations. Just think about his first proposal to Lizzy. Wasn't it the worst moment ever? She was so annoyed about him!<br />Merry Christmas to all!]<br /><br />I am so glad that you enjoyed the interview. And my impression about Mr. Darcy as a hero due to his willingness to change. For me that IS the fantasy of Mr. Darcy. To have a man that would go to THAT extreme to win me! And to be rich and handsome at the same time..LOL. Yes..the first proposal was horrible..for both of them.<br /><br />Merry Christmas to you! Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-86991004321998372022011-12-23T19:16:29.851+01:002011-12-23T19:16:29.851+01:00[ Farida Mestek said...
The book sounds very inter...[ Farida Mestek said...<br />The book sounds very interesting and intriguing! I'd love to have the chance to read it. Thank you for the giveaway!]<br /><br />Farida:<br /><br />I am so glad that the interview made the book look interesting. I wish you luck on the give away! And have a Happy Christmas!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-22289747977070632322011-12-23T19:15:11.928+01:002011-12-23T19:15:11.928+01:00[ Patricia said...
Nice interview! It's always...[ Patricia said...<br />Nice interview! It's always amazing to read about Mr. Darcy<br />Thanks for the giveaway!]<br /><br />Patricia:<br /><br />Thanks. I am so glad you enjoyed the interview. And I DO agree with you! A day without Darcy is like a Day without Sunshine! Merry Christmas! Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-85912022552547423652011-12-23T19:11:10.441+01:002011-12-23T19:11:10.441+01:00[marilyn said...
Great interview about these 2 top...[marilyn said...<br />Great interview about these 2 topics!<br /><br />Thanks for the giveaway.<br />marilyn ]<br /><br />Marilyn:<br /><br />I am so glad that you enjoyed it. Good luck with the give away!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-43957728287418134252011-12-23T19:09:55.413+01:002011-12-23T19:09:55.413+01:00[BeckyC said...
What a fun idea, especially for th...[BeckyC said...<br />What a fun idea, especially for this time of year. And a combo of your two favorite stories...perfect! <br />Thanks for the giveaway!]<br /><br />Becky:<br /><br />So glad that you like the idea and hope you enjoy the story as well. Have a Wonderful Christmas! Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-1471174451465799272011-12-23T19:08:45.072+01:002011-12-23T19:08:45.072+01:00[Margaret said...
I think this is such a great ide...[Margaret said...<br />I think this is such a great idea! I'd love to read this! Thanks!<br /><br />Margaret]<br /><br />Margaret: Thanks so much for taking the time to comment. I wish you good luck! Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-85853132548094837992011-12-23T19:07:43.139+01:002011-12-23T19:07:43.139+01:00[Kate @ Musings said...
How delightful to combine ...[Kate @ Musings said...<br />How delightful to combine two of your favorites stories! I would love the chance to see Mr. Darcy change in order to win his love! What a fantastic interview, and makes me want to read this book even more! Happy Christmas, All!]<br /><br />Kate: Thank you so much for your wonderful comment. I also thank Maria for her questions and the opportunity to do the interview here at My Jane Austen Book Club. I hope you have a very Happy Christmas!<br /><br />Barbara Tiller ColeBarbara Tiller Colehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15237523278334072442noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-21836669861279064032011-12-23T12:31:20.758+01:002011-12-23T12:31:20.758+01:00Nice interwiev! Thanks Maria Grazia.
I agree with ...Nice interwiev! Thanks Maria Grazia.<br />I agree with the author when she says that Mr. Darcy is a hero because of his being willing to change.<br />I think JA enjoyed herself a lot in creating a proud character just to put him later through the most "embarassing" situations. Just think about his first proposal to Lizzy. Wasn't it the worst moment ever? She was so annoyed about him!<br />Merry Christmas to all!<br />carrer.loredana@yahoo.itAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-44538174356779114672011-12-23T12:14:56.252+01:002011-12-23T12:14:56.252+01:00The book sounds very interesting and intriguing! I...The book sounds very interesting and intriguing! I'd love to have the chance to read it. Thank you for the giveaway!<br /><br />faridamestek@yahoo.comPhoebe's Sistershttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03548739602100284299noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-58926843672725634622011-12-23T11:17:19.885+01:002011-12-23T11:17:19.885+01:00Nice interview! It's always amazing to read ab...Nice interview! It's always amazing to read about Mr. Darcy<br />Thanks for the giveaway!<br />pato3_89@hotmail.comPatricianoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-77791792368722638522011-12-23T01:50:08.659+01:002011-12-23T01:50:08.659+01:00Great interview about these 2 topics!
Thanks for ...Great interview about these 2 topics!<br /><br />Thanks for the giveaway.<br />marilyn <br />daniel423@centurytel.netmarilynhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08458417858538216872noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-55783000488396424072011-12-23T01:16:45.844+01:002011-12-23T01:16:45.844+01:00What a fun idea, especially for this time of year....What a fun idea, especially for this time of year. And a combo of your two favorite stories...perfect! <br />Thanks for the giveaway!<br />cherringtonmb@sbcglobal.netBeckyChttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07858125894873568419noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-23783285420961677912011-12-22T17:22:25.496+01:002011-12-22T17:22:25.496+01:00I think this is such a great idea! I'd love to...I think this is such a great idea! I'd love to read this! Thanks!<br /><br />Margaret<br />singitm(at)hotmail(dot)comLiterary Chanteusehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11618034360122552670noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-8954683999390981517.post-10474157983050489002011-12-22T16:33:15.572+01:002011-12-22T16:33:15.572+01:00How delightful to combine two of your favorites st...How delightful to combine two of your favorites stories! I would love the chance to see Mr. Darcy change in order to win his love! What a fantastic interview, and makes me want to read this book even more! Happy Christmas, All!<br />oreannie at yahoo comKate Maxwellhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04342220424771084070noreply@blogger.com