Showing posts with label Fanny Price. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fanny Price. Show all posts

Tuesday, 19 September 2023

JANE AUSTEN'S LEADING LADIES: VIRTUES AND FLAWS

 

Jennifer Ehle as Elizabeth Bennet and Colin Firth as Mr Darcy (1995)

After discussing heroes, let’s have a look at Jane Austen's female leading characters. Her novels are filled with a cast of strong and memorable heroines, each with her unique set of virtues and flaws. From the witty Elizabeth Bennet to the reserved Fanny Price, these female protagonists have charmed readers for generations. In this article, I’d like to explore the world of Austen's heroines, highlighting both their admirable qualities and their human imperfections.

Thursday, 26 October 2017

LONA MANNING & KYRA KRAMER: FANNY VS MARY - GUEST POST + GIVEAWAY


Hello, I'm Lona Manning, author of A Contrary Wind: a variation on Mansfield Park.  and author of true crime articles available at http://www.crimemagazine.com/category/authors/lona-manning.

And I'm Kyra Kramer, author of  Mansfield Parsonage and the nonfictional historical books, Blood Will Tell, The Jezebel Effect, Henry VIII’s Health in a Nutshell, and Edward VI in a Nutshell.

Lona: Please join us for the knock-down drag-out (maybe) Fanny versus Mary debate of the decade/epoch/millennium. We will take turns posing each other questions. Please feel free to join in, in the comments!


Kyra: Everyone who comments will be entered in a draw to win a gift pack of Austen goodies from Bath, England. 

Thursday, 21 August 2014

LOVELY JANEITES: MEET SARAH OZCANDARLI, AUTHOR OF REVISIT MANSFIELD PARK + GIVEAWAY

Many thanks to Maria Grazia for giving me the opportunity to introduce my new book Revisit Mansfield Park, in which I give Henry Crawford the opportunity to change Fanny Price's opinion of him.
Jane Austen said of Henry: “Would he have deserved more there can be no doubt that more would have been obtained . . . Would he have persevered, and uprightly, Fanny must have been his reward.”
During Henry's two-month courtship of Fanny, she had no idea that his interest in her was genuine. She assumed that Henry was amusing himself by flirting with her, as he had with Maria and Julia Bertram. When Fanny finally learned that Henry truly wanted to marry her, he had only a few days to change her mind about him, but a few days was not nearly enough, given that Fanny disliked Henry intensely. Then Fanny went to see the Price family in Portsmouth, and Henry visited Fanny there, and talked to her of Everingham, his estate. He asked Fanny for her advice as to whether he should return to Everingham and continue the work he had started. I think what Henry really wanted was encouragement, and this was a pivotal moment: if Fanny encouraged Henry, he would be making progress with her, and if she did not, she most likely never would. This is the moment when Revisit Mansfield Park begins (though the first three chapters summarize Jane Austen's Mansfield Park, with a spotlight on Fanny).

Monday, 9 August 2010

MURDER AT MANSFIELD PARK by LYNN SHEPHERD

MURDER SHE WROTE… AND NOT ONLY!


UK cover for Murder at Mansfield Park

I’ve just finished reading “Murder at Mansfield Park” , first published novel by Lynn Shepherd .

 My response? 5 stars!

1 star for helping me get rid of Fanny Price. Why I have never liked her much, I’ve never really been able to explain (though I tried here and here) , but now I know. I had always suspected she hid “something”

1 star for making Fanny and Mary Crawford rivals again but with … different results

1 star for Lynn skillful hold of Austen-like language which resulted in a greatly enjoyable style

1 star for the many unexpected twists and surprising turns (especially the final unveiling of the mystery)

1 star for the Agatha Christie- style investigation

Very well drawn and very pleasantly written Lynn Shepherd’s Austen- inspired murder story is a perfect summer read I heartedly recommend both to Janeites and to the lovers of good old-fashioned detective stories from the classic tradition . In fact, Murder at Mansfield Park takes Austen’s masterpiece and turns it into a riveting murder story worthy of PD James or Agatha Christie. If Jane Austen would have turned to murder stories she might have written something like this.

The most pleasant surprise is the heroine of Shepherd’s novel, Mary Crawford. She  is self - confident, intelligent, witty as well as brave and resembles Elizabeth Bennet more than herself in Austen’s original novel. What of Fanny Price in this book, instead ? I don’t want to reveal much so as not to spoil your own pleasure at discovering the many intriguing devices which keep you guessing until the very last page . But I think I can tell you what follows without spoiling your future  pleasure : Lynn Shepherd shaped her Fanny according to what Kinglsley Amis wrote in an article originally published in The Spectator in October 1957 (“What became of Jane Austen”?) . In that article Fanny is defined as a “monster of complacency and pride, who under a cloak of cringing self-abasement, dominates and gives meaning to the novel”. So, can you guess? Neither Mary nor  Fanny are quite what we all believed them to be reading Mansfield Park.

I remember our discussion about Jane Austen's Mansfield Park at the public library last April  . Our group readers were quite convinced that the proper matching for the characters in the novel was Henry Crawford /Fanny and Mary Crawford/ Edmund . They didn’t quite like Austen’s decision to make Edmund and Fanny marry in the end, they found it an unsatisfactory ending. Moreover, apart from the two kind more mature ladies in the group, all the young readers preferred Mary to Fanny. It seems Lynn Shepherd knew about our wishes while writing. Well, we are only a small sample  of Jane Austen's contemporary audience and I'm sure  there are, of course, different opinions on Mansfield Park among the huge number of Janeites,  but I’m sure the majority would like this novel very much and find it  more playful and  even lighter than the original.

An interesting change respect to Jane Austen's novel is the relevance Lynn Shepherd gives to servants, maids and  Mansfield Park  staff  in general.  O'Hara, Mrs Baddeley or Polly Evans are minor characters but not bit players and they have an active role in the plot and in the solution of the mystery.

More than Edmund or Henry Crawford the hero in this murder story is Mr Maddox, the thief taker employed by the family  to investigate on the mysterious murder at Mansfield. His unpleasant manners, smart deductions, overwhelming will make him the real male protagonist of this novel. He hides his passionate heart and even his knowledge and education behind his rude ways. Guess what? I’d like to see him in action in a new adventure. He deserves more. I hope Lynn Shepherd doesn't want to discharge him after his brilliant contribution to her first novel.

As I wrote in the title,  the murder case/s are not the only interest in the book. You’ve got in fact the entire range of Austen’s main themes such as  family life, life in the country, marriage, elopment, gossip, love and the unfailing happy ending .

So, if you like me have always put Mansfield Park away with a certain unsatisfied feeling in the end, I’m sure you’ll love what Lynn Shepherd did of its plot and protagonists in full respect of the Austenesque tradition. Toward the end she writes: “Everything was clear to Mary now: even the smallest elements of the riddle had found their true place”. This is the impression I got once I closed the book at the last page,  everything and everyone had found their own place in Lynn Shepherd’s work.

Friday, 30 April 2010

READY FOR TOMORROW'S MEETING?

Tomorrow is Manfield Park day for our reading group. Our meeting is at 5 p.m in the afternoon. I must confess - I have already written this somewhere, I think - I always fear one of our meeting might  turn out something like this ... (watch the video below)




What disappointment for the Vicar! But what fun for us watching them!

While I was  getting my notes and videos ready , suddenly something came to mind: I hadn't posted the answers to the questions!  So, here they are at last.

Answers to the questions posted here

I / I How many children do the Price family have, and what are theirnames and ages at the start of the novel's main narrative?
Mrs Price (poor woman) has ten successful pregnancies in all, and Mary dies, leaving nine surviving Price children. They are, in descending order: William, Fanny, John (offstage), Richard (offstage), Susan, Mary (deceased), Sam, Tom, Charles, and finally little Betsey. When the sisters, as recorded in the opening pages, renew contact, Mrs Price has eight children (Mary still being alive) and is expecting her ninth, Charles.  Fanny, going then to Mansfield Park and never revisiting her home, does not meet Charles and Betsey until she returns to Portsmouth years later.


1/2 How recently has Mrs Norris seen her sister, Mrs Price, at the time of the novel's main action? 
She says 'she had not seen her poor dear sister Price for more than twenty years'. Even after the reconciliation which was sealed with the dispatch of Fanny, and despite the fact that she is Betsey's godmother, she has not made the relatively short (thirty-six-hour by coach) trip to Portsmouth. Presumably, (wealthy) skinflint that she is, Mrs Norris begrudges the expense of travel and overnight accommodation at an inn. Nor has Mrs Price ever been received at Mansfield Park. Which raises the question: after Fanny marries Edmund, will she be invited?



1/3 What argument does Mrs Norris adduce for the safety of introducing a girl into the Bertram family—specifically with regard to the two young sons of the family?

'Breed her up with them . . . and suppose her even to have the beauty of an angel, and she will never be more to either than a sister.' Mary Crawford, much later, observes that Fanny does indeed have a look of Edmund sometimes—a brother-sister similarity of feature.

I/4 Where does Miss Lee teach her three charges (Maria, Julia,and—latterly—Fanny) and what happens to the school-room?
It is the East room: so chosen because it will get the early morning light—when lessons begin. Facing east, it will also be cold, which is why Mrs Norris's prohibition on a fire being lit there, after Fanny takes it over as her study on Miss Lee's departure, is so cruel.


1/5 Who does Mrs Norris declare can help Fanny dress herself?
Either of the housemaids (that is, not a personal attendant, but a skivvy whose normal work is room cleaning).
1/6 How much older are Julia and Maria than Fanny?
Two and three years, respectively. Tom (a Cambridge man—who evidently spent more time at the racecourse at Newmarket than in his classroom) is seven years older, and Edmund (whose absence at
Eton and Oxford is only summarily described) is a couple of years younger than Tom.


1/7 How often does Fanny see William in the nine years she spends at Mansfield Park, and how often other members of her family?
She sees William twice. On the second occasion, when she is 18, they return together to Portsmouth. She has seen no member of her family—even on the occasion of the death of a favourite sister, Mary—in the intervening years.

1/8 How much income does Mrs Norris have?
Six hundred pounds a year, and free tenancy in the estate's 'White House'. She is rich. Presumably her elderly husband was as frugal as she.

1/9 What advantageous physical attributes does Henry Crawford possess?
He has good teeth, a pleasing address, 'so much countenance', and is 'well made' (that is, he has an athletic figure). But he is said to be 'plain' and, as the lofty (but stupid) Mr Rushworth points out, is short in stature—ambiguously five foot eight or  nine inches. From which we may assume that Rushworth is a bulky six-footer.
 
I / IO What does Dr Grant think to be 'an insipid fruit at the best'?
Apricots, thus condemning Mrs Norris's boasts about her superior Moor Park tree.
 
I / I I Why has Mary Crawford never ridden a horse, before coming to Mansfield (and appropriating Fanny's steed)?

It is odd. One assumes that her life has been entirely metropolitan and that she has never even spent any time at Everingham. But riding is not a universal attainment among the women in Jane Austen's world (can Emma ride, or Elizabeth?).

1/12 Who sits alongside Henry on the 'barouche box' on the visit to Sotherton?
 'Happy Julia'. Maria seethes. It is, of course, Mrs Grant who has placed Julia there as the eligible sister, hoping, evidently, that a match might be made. Maria is spoken for.


1/13 What are the 'curious pheasants'?
Ornamental breeds, as opposed to the preserved birds which Mr Rushworth's keepers raise at Sotherton. The ornamental birds were for ladies, as decorative garden pets. The preserved pheasants, in the nearby woods and moors, were for gentlemen to shoot.

1/14 Why did Mrs Whitaker, the housekeeper at Sotherton, turn away two housemaids?
For wearing white gowns—a privilege reserved for the ladies of the house. Fanny, for example, has a
white gown at her first dinner party; as Edmund gallantly says on that occasion, 'A woman can never be too fine while she is all in white.' A woman, but not a maidservant.


1/15 What is Fanny Price's favourite reading?
Poetry, biography,and improving essays. Not, definitely not, fiction.

1/16 Who is driven from home by a green goose?

Henry and Mary. Their reverend brother-in-law takes offence (becomes violent, indeed) when served a bird which has not been hung long nough. Without refrigerators it is a complex thing to have a bird 'mature' enough for the table—particularly the table of the epicurean Revd Dr Grant. At least, being fifteen years older than his wife, and a glutton, he will dig his grave with his teeth in a few years.


1/17 Where did Tom Bertram meet the Honourable John Yates?
At Weymouth, playground of wastrels in Austen's fiction.

1/18 Who divulges to Sir Thomas that private theatricals were inprospect?
Lady Bertram, who has lazily not followed the rehearsals and knows scarcely more about it than her amazed
husband.


1/19 Who says, pathetically, 'Every body gets made but me?
William. Promoted in the naval service, he means. He is, thanks to Admiral Crawford, eventually 'made' a lieutenant, and his career takes off.

1/20 What does William bring Fanny from Sicily?
 A 'very pretty amber cross'. Mary, symbolically, gives her a 'chain' to go with it. As she does so, Mary has a look around her eyes that Fanny 'could not be satisfied with'. As the reader will understand, Miss Crawford is scheming to capture the young girl for her brother.


1/21 What vessel is William posted to, after his promotion to lieutenant?
'H.M. sloop Thrush*.

1/22 Who thinks the alphabet 'hergreatest enemy'?
Little Betsey.

1/23 When she says 'what a difference a vowel makes \ what vowel is Mary Crawford thinking of?

The Hon. Mr John Yates 'rants' in his performance as Baron Wildenhaim. But he has not the 'rents', or income, to claim Julia as his bride.

1/24 How much does Sir Thomas give Fanny on her departure for Portsmouth?
Ten pounds. She does not, as she might, give the money to her mother. Part of it she expends on a silver knife for Betsey, another part on membership of the Portsmouth circulating library.
 
1/25 Where does Tom have the accident which precipitates the fever which leads, eventually, to his moral regeneration?
At Newmarket, drunkenly we presume, after a day at the races.

(Screencaps from angelfish /spikesbint Live Journal)

Questions & Answers from

Monday, 19 April 2010

THIS MONTH'S HEROINE - FANNY PRICE

THE HEROINE  - FANNY PRICE
Fanny Price is absolutely unique among Jane Austen's heroines. First of all her social rank, her background. She doesn't come from the country gentry, she is saved from poverty and a doomed destiny by her rich relatives. She is the daughter of a drunken sailor and of a woman who married beneath her when she comes to live with her wealthy uncle and aunt, Sir Thomas and Lady Bertram. Her mother has to ... send her away, because she has a hard time striving to get a living for all her children . They take her in as an act of charity to her parents. She is mistreated and always reminded of her "place" as a charity ward.

 Modest, always proper, and, as she grows older, quite beautiful, she eventually comes to be an indispensable member of the family. Her being a model heroine makes her again different from the other protagonists  in Austen's major novels. They are not always prim and proper, they are not flawless and they are all livelier than Fanny, even sensible Elinor and good-hearted, patient Ann Elliot. Mind you, this is my opinion, or the impression I get reading this novel again this month. Someone has compared her to the passive, prudish heroine of Richardson's Pamela, or Virtue Rewarded (Ornella De Zordo, "Il prezzo della virtù: la storia di Fanny Price e della sua perfezione" , The Price of Virtue, the History of Fanny Price and her Perfection). But Mansfield Park is not an easy reading and her heroine is again a means in the hands of her creator. Comedy is less direct in Mansfield Park and irony is subtler and more difficult to be caught. Anyhow, the female model embodied by the protagonist is the target of Austen's irony as well as those who, reading her story, might share and appreciate her values.

But what are her values? Fanny represents a moralistic-evangelical model in women's education, opposing her  aristocatic and sentimental cousins Mariah and Julia. She easily wins in the comparisons with her cousins but harder is for her to come forward if compared to clever, free and unprejudiced Mary Crawford. I have already borught about this point in my previous post about Mansfield Park. One of Fanny's limits, for instance, seems to be little spontaneous, condemned to play the part of the perfect young lady, incapable of expressing freely her thoughts and feelings and even of distinguishing between her real wishes and her sense of duty.
Finally, respect to her Elizabeth Bennet ,  Marianne Dashwood or Emma Woodhouse look  very rebellious and modern heroines.
Guess what? I hope I'll find someone among my mates at the reading club who will convince me I'm totally wrong with  poor Fanny and will help me to admire her a bit more. So far, hard task.

In the adaptation I've watched so far (1999 & 2007) Fanny is  more livelier and enterprising of the girl portrayed by Jane Austen. In the 1999 film Fanny (Frances O'Connor) is a writer and at the end of the movie Edmund ( Jonny Lee Miller ) tells her her novel is going to be published. In the 2007 ITV version Fanny has the naughty smile and provoking charm of Billie Piper and, as I've alredy stated several times,  I can't see Fanny in her acting.

This is all for today. I challenge you to a hard task. Would you please try to convince me I'm totally wrong about Fanny? Partially wrong can be enough, so that I can go on re-reading her story with a different perspective.  I hope I have time to discuss here the many important  themes and features in Mansfield Park before April 30th, because there are many and very serious. This novel is really challenging and interesting to one fond of literary texts like me, so don't worry I am enjoying the experience of going through it again. If I haven't got time, I'll write about them in my journal of the next meeting.
Now, I'll leave you with a  quiz with self correction about Mansfield Park. If you want to try it, CLICK HERE. What was your score at it?