Friday, 20 November 2026

MURDER, MYSTERY AND A RETURN TO BATH: AN INTERVIEW WITH VICTORIA GROSSACK

 



What happens after Jane Austen's Persuasion comes to its long-awaited happy ending? Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth have finally found their way back to each other, but surely their story doesn't have to end there!

In The Bath Murders: A Mystery Set in the City of Jane Austen's Persuasion, author Victoria Grossack invites us to revisit some of Austen's most beloved characters, this time against the backdrop of a mysterious and unsettling Bath in 1816, the famous "Year Without a Summer."

Combining her love of Jane Austen with the pleasures of a traditional whodunit, Grossack brings Anne and Frederick Wentworth into a new chapter of their lives, where marriage, family, and plans for the future meet unexpected dangers and intriguing mysteries.

The fourth instalment in her series of Austen-inspired mysteries, The Bath Murders offers readers a chance to discover what might have happened beyond the final pages of Persuasion, while exploring the fascinating social world of Regency Bath.

I'm delighted to welcome Victoria Grossack to My Jane Austen Book Club to talk about the inspiration behind her latest mystery, the challenges of writing about Austen's characters, the historical details that shaped her story, and why Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth still have so much to tell us.

Join us for a fascinating conversation about Jane Austen, second chances, and, of course, murder!

Sally Hawkins as Anne Elliott in Persuasion 2007


Persuasion is often considered Jane Austen's most mature and reflective novel. What was it about this particular story and its setting in Bath that inspired you to write The Bath Murders?

The Bath Murders is my fourth of my Jane-Austen-novel-based mysteries. You can already read The Meryton Murders (Pride & Prejudice), The Highbury Murders (Emma) and The Mansfield Park Murders (Mansfield Park). The Bath Murders (Persuasion) was the logical next step, and to be true to the series, it had to be set in Bath.

The project gave me some trouble. Persuasion is beloved by many people, but I found the leads frustrating. Given their maturity, Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth should have been able to talk to each other and resolve things immediately. If Anne just gave Wentworth a smile when they met again, or asked him how he was, he would have melted. Of course, there would have been no novel!

But as I read and reread the text – something I do while writing these mysteries, to get the details and the characters right – I forgave Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth. Yes, they took the entire novel to get back together, but the number of days was not really that long. They meet again sometime in early October 1814, and the accident in Lyme is sometime in November. So that’s just a little more than a month during which they are separated by their own hesitations. After that, of course, Wentworth has to wait to be released by Louisa’s engagement to Captain Benwick.

After spending in-depth time with these characters, and realizing that Wentworth, for all his anger and pain, made moves both to take protect Anne and finally to woo her again, I learned to care for them. Their intense love for each other coupled with their insecurities – she had refused him; he had not come back for eight years – prevented them from behaving rationally. The Bath Murders was a delight to write because, despite the worries and the murders, I could show their happiness together, something I hope will please those who love Persuasion.

So, basically, The Bath Murders was next on my list. But then I found the story and I am very pleased with it.

In Persuasion, we see a world in which the Royal Navy has become an important source of status and opportunity. Did this social landscape influence the world you created for your mystery?

At first I thought I should write about the Royal Navy, as so many characters in Persuasion – Captain Wentworth, Admiral Croft, and Captains Harville and Benwick – are naval officers. Certainly Jane Austen, in her later years, was concerned with the sea, thanks to her brothers Francis and Charles, who both eventually became admirals. But the research required for such a project was daunting, and not that interesting. If something is daunting and uninteresting to me, it will be daunting and uninteresting to readers.

Only when I changed the focus, and centered the plot on Anne and her relatives, did a story come into being. Still, the fact that Captain Wentworth is in the navy means he is a man of action. This is different from the other male leads in her earlier books, who are either clergymen (like Austen’s father) or who have estates of their own (like Austen’s brother Edward Austen Knight, who was adopted by rich cousins). Wentworth needs purpose; Wentworth needs something to do; Wentworth solves problems. Admiral Croft also executes things quickly. Even Colonel Wallis, although army and not navy, is practical about getting things done.

So, in The Bath Murders Captain Wentworth is making plans, working to start a business, while Sir Walter is concerned with his appearance in the mirror and the glory of being a baronet.

Ciaran Hinds as Captain Wentworth in Persuasion 1995


One of the most interesting aspects of Persuasion is the contrast between Anne Elliot, whose life is full of thoughtful interests and practical concerns, and her sister Elizabeth, who seems much more preoccupied with appearances. How important is the idea of a woman having a meaningful purpose in life to your story?

Although Anne has no official career in The Bath Murders, she assists Captain Wentworth as he reviews potential business ventures. Elizabeth is only concerned with her rank – going first in and out of rooms – and with her looks and playing cards.

The Bath Murders opens – tiny spoiler! – with the announcement of the marriage between Mr. Elliot and Mrs. Clay, something hinted at as a possibility at the end of Persuasion. As Elizabeth still hoped to marry Mr. Elliot, this event causes Elizabeth to reach out to Anne more than she has. Elizabeth’s shallowness is still supreme, but she is more concerned with her future than she has been.

Anne, with her family and friends and her projects, is much happier than Elizabeth.

Your novel is set in 1816, the famous “Year Without a Summer”, when unusual weather conditions affected much of Europe. What drew you to this particular historical moment and how did the extraordinary weather shape the atmosphere of your story?

As most of the events of Persuasion take place in the autumn of 1814, and we can presume that Anne and Captain Wentworth marry in early 1815, and I wanted them to be expecting their first child, The Bath Murders had to be set in 1816. My research into that year showed it was the year without a summer, and so I just made the weather mostly awful. The bad weather made it plausible, too, to set the story in Bath. Captain Wentworth and Anne have been living with Admiral and Mrs. Croft at Kellynch Estate – the Crofts love having the Wentworths with them, and basically won’t let them leave – but the terrible weather makes Bath far more inviting than Kellynch, where they would be isolated by mud, snow and impassable roads.

Bath is almost a character in its own right in Persuasion. How did you approach recreating the city for The Bath Murders and were there particular places, historical details or aspects of its social life that you especially wanted to include?

Setting the story in Bath makes it possible to include more of Persuasion’s characters, such as Sir Walter and Elizabeth and even Lady Russell, who winters in Bath. Other characters, not as central to Persuasion, such as Mrs. Smith and Nurse Rooke and Colonel Wallis, play more important roles in The Bath Murders.  

The fact that Bath is a city as opposed to a village or an estate in the country allows for much more interaction: being able to walk to shops, the crowds, the gardens (admittedly not at their best) and the cobblestone roads. Central to the mystery is the fact that Bath was known as a place to take cures, such as drinking the waters at the Pump room. I assumed the city would be full of various medical practitioners – physicians, doctors, nurses and apothecaries – as people searched for cures for various ailments.

When writing a mystery inspired by an Austen novel, there's an interesting balance between honouring the original world and creating something entirely your own. How did you approach this, and did Austen's characters or themes ever lead your story in an unexpected direction?

All Jane Austen’s works are basically about sex, status and money. In The Bath Murders, these are still important, but as Anne and Captain Wentworth are already married, they are not concerned about the uncertainties of romance. Instead they are working on making lives for themselves: starting a family, finding a business, setting down roots.

When working on any story, I ask why some things happen, but also why other things do not. For example, a central question to me in The Bath Murders was: Why had Sir Walter not remarried by 1814? Austen gives some reasons in Persuasion, but I developed another, based on a detail in Persuasion.

Then there were the usual challenges encountered by mystery writers. Who dies? Who commits the murder(s)? Why don’t people figure it out immediately and what leads to the gradual understanding and the grand reveal? How can I arrange events and discoveries so the story is both intellectually and emotionally satisfying?

Setting a story in Jane Austen’s time means the mystery is not burdened by the forensics of today. Current criminal investigation techniques - DNA, cameras, digital footprints - are great for catching actual perpetrators but leave less to readers’ imaginations. One can revel in old-fashioned clues such as a mysterious snuffbox and a ruffian’s unibrow. Also, my research shows that Bath did not have much of a police force at the time, which allows my characters to get involved in the detective work.

Although I try to stay true to the characters, the plot choices are my own.

Finally, what do you hope readers who love Persuasion will enjoy most about The Bath Murders? And can readers who haven't read Austen's novel still fully enjoy your mystery?

An author must choose the audience, and The Bath Murders is designed mostly for people familiar with Persuasion. One friend of mine complained about the great number of characters introduced in the first chapter, but he does not know Persuasion. For those acquainted with Austen’s novel, the mentions of characters are not introductions but information about what their beloved friends are currently doing.

So, The Bath Murders will be more work for a reader unfamiliar with Persuasion. But Jane Austen’s characters are so well-defined that they leap off the page. I think The Bath Murders would please any lover of the old-fashioned mystery.

Finally, for those who love Persuasion, a great frustration is how little respect Anne receives. In The Bath Murders, readers will get to see how much she is cherished by the Crofts and Captain Wentworth – and, unbeknownst to her, how much she has been respected – by so many all along.

Victoria Grossack’s The Bath Murders: A Mystery Set in the City of Jane Austen’s Persuasion is available at Amazon.

No comments: